A thousand-year-old Armenian church has been renovated and re-opened by Turkish authorities
The church re-opened as a museum on March 29th, after a year-long restoration: although the two countries don’t have any diplomatic
relations after Hrant Dink’s murder and Turkey's denial of the Armenian genocide,
representatives from both Armenia and Turkey were present at the inauguration
ceremony. Even Armenian patriarch Mesrob II was there.
A church without a cross. The ancient Armenian Church of the Holy Cross was built between 915 and 921 C.E.
on Akdamar island in the middle of lake Van, on eastern Turkey’s border with Armenia.
Nobody took care of this magnificent building during the First World War when
1.5 million people were killed in what has been called “the Armenian genocide”.
Heavy rains and strong winds eroded its structure and weakened the roof. Turkish
authorities spent almost 1.5 million euro to finance its restoration that started
in 2005. Despite this good work, controversy seemed to hover over the event: there’s
no cross on the apex of the church’s dome, even if the Armenian Church requested
such symbol to be put there. Akdamar is no more a place of cult (like Aya Sofia
in Istanbul), there’s no need for a cross on a museum.
The re-opening event. Akdamar re-opened on Thursday, Mar.29th. The Turkish and Armenian culture ministers, other Turkish functionaries, Armenian
religious men and historians were present. Even patriarch Mesrob II, leader of
60.000 Armenians living in Turkey, attended the ceremony: he suggested an annual
pilgrimage should be made to the church. The Armenian Church’s supreme leader
Karekin II refused to be there: he didn’t approve the transformation of Akdamar
Church into a museum. And on that very day, the church was also decorated with
Turkish flags and a poster of Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, the founder of the Turkish
Republic. There were no Armenian flags.
Edgy ties. Akdamar church is located on an island in lake Van, on eastern Turkey’s border
with Armenia. There are no diplomatic relations between these two countries, divided
by a border that was closed by Turkey to support Azerbaijan in the fight for Nagorno-Karabakh
in 1993. The Armenian delegation had to pass through Georgia to reach Turkey.
The genocide issue – a taboo in Turkey - has become a central matter in the last
few days.
Hrant Dink, a writer and journalist, was gunned down by a young Turkish nationalist
in January: he had been given a six-month suspended sentence as his view on the
Armenian genocide was different from Ankara’s official version: Turkey claims
those Armenian victims were a part of World War I in the dying days of the Ottoman
empire in the fight against Russia.
Bilateral relations between the US and Turks are becoming tense because of this
denial: Washington Congress is planning a resolution that would classify the widespread
killings of Armenians by the Ottoman Turkish government early in the 20th century
as genocide.